Note – This article had to be substantially updated on 21/Nov/2026 after a visit to the National Archives where I discovered that Sarah was not the daughter of Nathan Chambers. Further sleuthing has uncovered that she was almost certainly the daughter of his brother Joseph Chambers and that the DNA matches I had found to her were cousin matches not sibling matches. It is a salutary lesson in why it is important to do both paper and DNA research. I have left the article largely as I initially wrote it with a substantial update at the end – so you can see how the evidence revealed itself.

1.0 Background


Finding the correct family for Sarah Harris (wife to Henry Harris the Coach Plater) has involved many hours of sleuthing over the last six years.

When I first researched my ancestor Susan Phillis Harris most of the trees on Ancestry stated that her mother was a Sarah Walshaw from Shoreditch. But when I researched into the Henry and Sarah Harris marriages for the period there were so many options I could not see a particular reason to pick that one. So I decided to consider the other records to see if there was a more likely one. This involved researching a huge number of Harris families – all to no avail.

After considering many options I spotted this marriage where the Henry in question was from the Parish of St Martin in the Fields. I already knew that Henry and Sarah’s daughter (my ancestor) Susan Phillis Harris was baptised at St Martin in the Fields church a few years after this.

The wedding banns state that Henry is from the Parish of St Martin in the Fields.

I also found this document about a Henry Harris living in St Clements Danes working as a volunteer soldier. This also seemed to fit with my couple. Susan Phillis Harris was married at St Clement Danes church. Could this be our Henry and Sarah?

Pay for the wives of a militia substitute (part-time home defence force) in Clement Danes ( a substitue was a man paid to serve in place of someone chosen by ballot) – this describes that they were married at St Saviour’s although the dates are out by one year – again this could have been to hide a child born out of wedlock.

So next I started a record search for a Sarah Chambers on Ancestry and found a family in Camberwell which seem to fit the bill. This Sarah Ann Chambers would only have been 15 when she married Henry but it would have been shortly after her father died. So it felt quite likely plus according to the document above she would already have had a child when they married. The marriage contract states that Sarah is 22 however I believe it was quite common to lie if needed at that period. There was not much chance people would be caught.

From the records Sarah Ann Chambers was the third daughter to Nathan Chambers and Sarah Ann Bampton. Nathan was a farmer from Camberwell who seemed to farm alongside a couple of brothers. Camberwell would have been all fields and farms in the late 1700’s when Sarah was born.

So next I thought I would take a look at my DNA to see if this could possibly be our Sarah. In order to use the DNA tools in Ancestry effectively the best thing to do was to build out a tree of the Chambers family and build down to as many descendants as possible. I did this quite extensively. And to my surprise a few months later a match did pop up on my mother’s thrulines – it was a match to Jane Chambers – Sarah’s sister. I checked it thoroughly and it seemed accurate.

It was fairly amazing that this needle in a haystack approach had worked so I was now keen to consolidate this connection. The match had a shared match with another also connected to the Chambers family. I got in touch with some members of that family – strangely it was a match to a grandson but not to his mother or grandmother further up the line who had both tested their DNA. They should have been strong matches to my mother but she had no match to them. This was a bit suspicious especially since my mother seemed to have some paternal matches with the grandson. The match could be due to some other connection elsewhere in my mothers tree.

So in truth there really was only 1 decent match and one should not count a single match as sufficient proof of a link to a family. It is too easy to get incorrect connections by chance or via some other connection.

So what has followed has been a many year attempt to get a second match between Sarah and her siblings. Descendants of Sarah’s sisters Martha Chambers (1 set) and Jane Chambers (2 sets) shared their DNA with me shortly after finding that initial match and I examined them with a fine toothcomb. But I really had no luck.

I then got more involved in finding siblings for Susan Phillis Harris, with some success. From the research there are a set of four siblings with many matches between them which I have discussed in another post. To do this I managed to get a number of matches of matches to share their DNA with me which involved quite a lot of effort. Each were checked carefully but sadly none of this shared DNA seemed to have any links to the Chambers family.

Last week I was coming to terms with the fact that I should give up on the Chambers family of Camberwell. I thought perhaps if I attached a different wife to Henry I might be able to find some matches via thrulines that way – I even did some extensive searches for Sarah Walshaw’s relatives within all the matches I had.

However in a last ditch attempt to find some Chambers connections last weekend I wrote to over 100 descendants of Henry Harris to share some information I had written about him and to see if I could get any more DNA to look at. I really had got to the end of the road with the information I had.

Four very kind people shared their DNA with me in response. And to my shock one of them had a match to Martha Chambers. This is from another descendant of Susan Phillis Harris but via her first husband – the Rycroft line. For me this makes it even more solid as a finding. It was to a different Chambers sister and from a different part of the family than my mother’s. I am very pleased. Taken as a whole the five sets of DNA matches shown below really show quite comprehensively that these four sisters were a family. The fifth sister Sophia died aged 9 and the brother Joseph does not appear to have married.

Update: I found a third match to Sarah Ann Chambers from a descendant of Jane Chambers today (19 October 2026) see below as Match 3.

Update 2: And today I found a fourth match to Sarah Ann Chambers – my first between her and Susanna Chambers (24 October 2026). I have now added 10 sets of shared DNA to this post.

Update 3: Yesterday (20 November 2026) I went to the National Archives at Kew and captured a long document (Johnson v Upsdell) – I was a little wary that this document might reveal something I was not expecting. And indeed the 1830 Chancery bill (Johnson v. Upsdell, C 13/1499/44) brought by John Johnson and his wife Sarah Ann of Lambeth, describing her as Joseph Chambers’s (Nathan’s son b.1783) ‘natural and lawful sister. It names his only surviving sisters as Sarah Ann Johnson, Jane Mortlock and Susannah Upsdell, plus James Salmon for the dead sister Martha.

In other words Sarah Ann Chambers was not the Sarah I had been looking for. But I was confused by the DNA which did seem to indicate some connection. Yesterday evening I put all of the evidence into Claude and it suggested that the 4 matches that I have could well be cousin matches. I knew Peter did not have any children from reading his will. So then I looked more carefully at the Joseph Chambers (1742) – Nathan’s older brother. And luckily I found his marriage and eventually a daughter Sarah Chambers born in 1774. Her age fits her marriage, census and death records perfectly. I will share the information I found in section 3.

The bill of complaint Johnson v. Upsdell 1830, C 13/1499/44 (National archives)

Johnson v. Upsdell (Chancery, 1830): the bill of complaint

The National Archives, C 13/1499/44 (bill only). Bill of John Johnson and Sarah Ann his wife against Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife, William Mortlock and Jane his wife, and James Salmon, about the estate of their brother Joseph Chambers of Peckham Rye, farmer, who died intestate in January 1830. Filed 6 August 1830. Five pages.

Transcription conventions: spelling as written; [?] marks an uncertain reading; […] marks words not visible in the photographs; line breaks of the original are not kept. Words written above the line are shown with ^ … ^.

Page 1

Top of the page: Pollen [?] Aller [?] — 6 August 1830 — 44

To the Right Honorable John Singleton [Copley, struck through: Lord Lyndhurst] Baron Lyndhurst of Lyndhurst in the County of Southampton Lord High Chancellor of Great Britain

Humbly Complaining shew unto your Lordship your Orator and Oratrix John Johnson of No 13 Regent Street Lambeth in the County of Surrey Gentleman and Sarah Ann his wife That Joseph Chambers late of Peckham Rye in the parish of St Giles Camberwell in the County of Surrey Farmer was in his life time and at the time of his death hereinafter mentioned seized of or well entitled to him and his heirs in fee simple of or to a certain real estate consisting of a messuage or dwelling house farm hereditaments and premises situated at or near Peckham Rye in the parish of St Giles Camberwell in the County of Surrey and that he was also in his life time and at the time of his death possessed of or entitled to some considerable personal Estate and effects consisting amongst other particulars of Household furniture plate linen China monies in the House implements of Husbandry and Stock and Crops upon the aforesaid farm And your Orator and Oratrix further shew unto your Lordship that the said Joseph Chambers being so seized possessed and entitled as aforesaid departed this life Intestate in the month of January One thousand eight hundred and thirty and that he left your Oratrix and Jane Mortlock the wife of William Mortlock of the New Cut Lambeth aforesaid Butcher and Susannah Upsdell the wife of Isaac Upsdell of Peckham Rye aforesaid Caulker and which said William Mortlock and Jane his wife and Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife are Defendants hereinafter named his only Sisters surviving him and that the said Joseph Chambers had only one other Sister who died in his life time leaving James Salmon of Peckham in the County of Surry Carpenter who is the other Defendant hereinafter named her eldest son and heir at Law And your Orator and Oratrix further shew that the said Intestate was never married and that he left no Brother and no Issue of any Brother and that your Oratrix and the said Jane Mortlock and Susannah Upsdell and the said James Salmon are only in manner aforesaid the Coheirs of the said Intestate And that your Oratrix and the said said Jane Mortlock and Susannah Upsdell and the said James Salmon are also the persons who under the Statute of distributions [are] entitled to the residue of the said Intestates personal Estate and Effects And your Orator and Oratrix further shew unto your Lordship that on or about the twenty fourth day of February One thousand eight hundred and thirty Letters of administration of the Estate and Effects of the said Intestate were granted to your Oratrix and to the said Jane Mortlock and Susannah Upsdell as the natural and lawful Sisters of the said Intestate And that your Oratrix and the said Jane Mortlock and Susannah Upsdell thereby became and now are the legal personal Representatives of the said Intestate But that neither your Oratrix nor your Orator in her right nor as your Orator and Oratrix believe the said Jane Mortlock or the said William Mortlock her husband in her right have or hath received or paid any thing in respect of the said Intestates Estate And your Orator and Oratrix further shew unto your Lordship that the said Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife were stopping in the house with the said Intestate at the time of his death and that upon his death they possessed themselves of the money in his House his household furniture plate linen and China and other Effects and the Stock Crops implements of Husbandry and other property upon his farm and they have sold and converted into money the said Stock and Crops and part of the said other effects and they have out of the proceeds thereof paid his funeral Expences and Just Debts and they are in the possession of all the residue of the said Intestates Estate and Effects which are to a Considerable Amount and value the said Intestates debts having been very inconsiderable And your Orator and Oratrix further Shew that the said Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife also upon the death of the said Intestate possessed themselves of the several deeds and writings relating to the Title of the said real Estates and they also entered into the possession or into the Receipt of the Rents and Profits of his aforesaid Real Estate and they have ever since been and now are in the exclusive possession and enjoyment or in the receipt of the rents and profits of such real Estate And your Orator and Oratrix further shew that upon the Death of the said Intestate your Oratrix and the said Susannah Upsdell Jane Mortlock and James Salmon became entitled to the said Intestates said real Estates as Tenants in Common in equal fourth parts and that they are also or your Orator in right of your Oratrix and the said Isaac Upsdell and William Mortlock in right of their respective wives are entitled to equal fourth parts of the residue of the said Intestates personal Estate and effects And your Orator and Oratrix further shew that your Orator and Oratrix are desirous of having a proper Account taken of the said Intestates personal Estate and effects and of his funeral Expences and debts and to have the Clear residue of such personal Estate ascertained and divided and distributed in manner aforesaid and the enjoyment of the said Real Estate in Common being attended with inconvenience your Orator and Oratrix are desirous of having a partition made ^thereof^ between the Coheirs in order that your Oratrix[‘s] ^share and proportion thereof^ may be allotted to and held by your Oratrix in Severalty and of having the Title deeds and writings belonging to the Title to the said Estate deposited or disposed of in some proper manner for the benefit of the Coheirs And your Orator and Oratrix are also desirous of having a proper Account taken of the rents and profits of the said Real Estates accrued due since the said [struck: Intestate] ^Intestates^ death or an occupation Rent set upon the same and what is due and owing to your Oratrix or your Orator in her right in respect of your [struck: Orator’s] ^Oratrix’s^ fourth share thereof [struck word] duly paid And your Orator and Oratrix further shew unto your Lordship that under the Circumstances aforesaid they have frequently both by themselves and their Agents applied to the said Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife and requested them to come to an Account with your Orator and Oratrix of the personal Estate and Effects which the said Intestate was possessed of or entitled to at the time of his death which have been possessed by or come to the hands of the said Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife or of any person or persons by their Order or for their use And of his funeral Expences and debts and to ascertain the Clear residue of such personal Estate and Divide and Distribute the same in manner [aforesaid …]

Signed in the left margin: Gatty [counsel’s signature]

First line of the next sheet, partly visible: … his wife and James Salmon are unwilling to join your Orator and Oratrix as Plaintiffs in this suit …

Notes on page 1

  • Joseph Chambers died in January 1830, unmarried and intestate. He was “late of Peckham Rye … Farmer”, seized in fee simple of a house, farm and land at Peckham Rye, with household goods, plate, linen, china, money, farm implements, stock and crops. This settles his death date (the tree had 1820).
  • His heirs were his sisters. The bill names “your Oratrix” (Sarah Ann Johnson), Jane Mortlock (wife of William Mortlock of the New Cut, Lambeth, butcher) and Susannah Upsdell (wife of Isaac Upsdell of Peckham Rye, caulker) as “his only Sisters surviving him”, and one other sister who died in his lifetime leaving her eldest son and heir James Salmon of Peckham, carpenter. Joseph had no brother and no brother’s children.
  • Sarah Ann Johnson was Joseph’s sister. The plaintiff, Sarah Ann, wife of John Johnson of 13 Regent Street, Lambeth, gentleman, is stated to be his natural and lawful sister. So the “Sarah Ann Johnson” of the November 1830 partition was a Chambers sister, not a Salmon or an outsider.
  • Administration, 24 February 1830, was granted to Sarah Ann Johnson, Jane Mortlock and Susannah Upsdell jointly.
  • The complaint against the Upsdells. Isaac and Susannah were “stopping in the house” with Joseph when he died. They took his money, furniture, plate, linen and china, sold the stock and crops, paid the funeral and debts, kept the deeds and the rents, and refused to account. The Johnsons asked for an account, a division into four equal shares, and a partition of the land.
  • This led to the partition of November 1830. The deed recited in Susannah Upsdell’s 1832 will (Salmon, Upsdell, Johnson, Mortlock and John Clutton, about 6 acres 3 roods 8 perches) was the settlement of this suit.
  • Uncertain readings: the names at the top of the page (probably the solicitors), and the marginal signature (Gatty).

Page 2

Top of the page: 6 August 1830

[in manner] Aforesaid And your Orator and Oratrix have also requested them to join and concur with your Orator and Oratrix in having such partition of the said Intestates Real Estates made as aforesaid and to produce the said several Deeds and writings for the benefit of the Coheirs and your Orator and Oratrix have also requested them to come to such account of the rents and profits of the said real Estate as aforesaid and to pay to your Oratrix or to your Orator in her right her fourth part or share of what shall be found due upon that Account and your Orator and Oratrix well hoped that the said Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife would have [struck: applied] ^complied^ with such your Orator and Oratrix’s just and reasonable requests as in justice and equity they ought to have done But now so it is May it please your Lordship that the said Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife combining and confederating with the said William Mortlock and Jane his wife and James Salmon and with divers other persons at present unknown to your Orator and Oratrix whose names when discovered your Orator and Oratrix pray they may be at liberty to insert herein with apt words to charge them as parties Defendants hereto and contriving how to injure and oppress your Orator and Oratrix in the premises the said Confederates Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife absolutely refuse to comply with your Orator and Oratrix’s aforesaid requests or either of them sometimes pretending that the personal Estate and Effects which the said Intestate was possessed of or entitled to at the time of his death were of small Amount and value and not sufficient or more than sufficient for the payment of all his funeral expences and just debts and that the same have been all exhausted thereby Whereas your Orator and Oratrix charge the contrary of such pretences to be the truth and that the personal Estate and effects which the said Intestate was possessed of or entitled to at the time of his death were of large amount and value and much more than sufficient for the payment of all his funeral expences and just debts after payment whereof there remained in the hands of the said Confederates Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife a large sum of money being part of the residue of the personal Estate and Effects of the said Intestate And your Orator and Oratrix charge that so it would appear if the said Confederates last named would discover and setforth a full true and particular Account of all and singular the personal estate and effects which the said Intestate was possessed of or entitled at the time of his death together with the natures quantities qualities and true and utmost value thereof and of every part thereof and what part thereof have come to the hands of the said Confederates last named or either of them or to the hands of any other person or persons by their or either of their order or for their or either of their use and of the application of the same or of such parts thereof as have been applied or disposed of and what parts thereof remain outstanding and where and in whose hands and why the same have not been collected and got in and also a like account of the funeral and testamentary expences and just debts owing by the said Intestate at the time of his death and to whom and on what account the same were respectively owing and which of such debts have been paid or satisfied and out of what funds and also the amount of the monies now in the hands of the said last named Confederates in respect of the said Intestates personal estate and effects And at other times the said Confederates Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife pretend that the said Real Estate which the said Intestate was seized of or entitled to at the time of his death was of small value and that the rents and profits thereof received by them since the said Intestates death are to a very small and inconsiderable Amount Whereas your Orator and Oratrix charge the contrary of such pretences to be the truth and that the real Estate which the said Intestate died seized of or entitled to were of very large amount and value and that the rents and profits thereof received by the said Confederates last named since the said Intestates death were to a very large Amount And your Orator and Oratrix charge that so it would appear if the said Confederates Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife would setforth a list or schedule of the said Intestates Real Estates and where the same are respectively situate and of the respective rentals and annual value of the same since the death of the said Intestate together with an Account of all the rents and profits of such Real Estates respectively which have accrued due since the said Intestates decease and by whom the same have from time to time been received and to what amount respectively and when and from whom by name such rents and profits and every part thereof were and was received and in respect of what premises and when the same became due and how the said rents and profits of the said real Estates and every part thereof have been applied and disposed of and the amount of the monies now in the hands of the said Confederates last named in respect of the rents and profits of the said Intestates Real Estates And your Orator and Oratrix charge that the said Confederates Isaac Upsdell and Susannah [struck: his wife] ^Upsdell^ attempted to procure Administration of the said Intestates personal estate [struck: and effects] to be granted to the said Confederate Susannah Upsdell alone which your Orator and Oratrix prevented them from doing and they have since that time shewn much animosity and ill will towards your Orator and Oratrix and particularly towards your Orator and that your Orator has several times applied to the said Isaac Upsdell to be allowed to inspect the Accounts of the said Personal Estate and the said Confederate Isaac Upsdell has repeatedly refused to allow your Orator on behalf of your Oratrix to inspect such Accounts and considerable stock and Crops having been sold from off the said farm your Orator has applied to the said Confederate Isaac Upsdell to inform him what the same was sold for and what was the expence attending the getting in and disposing of the said Stock and crops but the said Confederate Isaac Upsdell has positively refused to give your Orator any information upon the subject And your Orator and Oratrix further charge that under the circumstances aforesaid some proper person ought to be appointed a Receiver of the said Intestates Estate and Effects with the usual directions And your Orator and Oratrix further charge that the said Confederates William Mortlock and Jane his wife and James Salmon are unwilling to join your Orator and Oratrix as Plaintiffs in this Suit …

Signed in the left margin: Gatty

Notes on page 2

  • The accusations against the Upsdells. They claimed Joseph’s goods barely covered his funeral and debts and that the land and rents were of small value; the Johnsons say the estate and rents were “of very large amount and value”, and that a large sum remained in the Upsdells’ hands.
  • Susannah tried to take sole administration. Isaac and Susannah tried to have letters of administration granted to Susannah alone. The Johnsons stopped them, which explains why administration (24 February 1830) went to the three sisters jointly.
  • A family quarrel. Since then the Upsdells had shown “much animosity and ill will”, especially towards John Johnson. Isaac repeatedly refused to let him see the accounts or say what the stock and crops had fetched.
  • The Mortlocks and James Salmon would not join the Johnsons as plaintiffs, so they were made defendants alongside the Upsdells. The bill asks for a receiver to be appointed to manage the estate.

Page 3

Top of the page: 6 Aug[us]t 1830

All which actings pretences and refusals of the said Confederates are contrary to equity and good conscience and tend to the manifest wrong and injury of your Orator and Oratrix In tender consideration whereof and for as much as your Orator and Oratrix are remediless in the premises at common law and can only be relieved in a Court of Equity where matters of this sort are properly cognizable and relievable To the end therefore that the said Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife William Mortlock and Jane his wife and James Salmon and their confederates when discovered may upon their several and respective corporal oaths according to the best and utmost of their several and respective knowledge remembrance information and belief full true perfect and distinct answer make to all and singular the matters aforesaid and that as fully and particularly as if the same were here repeated and they severally and respectively distinctly interrogated thereunto and more especially that the said Defendants may in manner aforesaid discover and setforth whether the said Joseph Chambers was not in his lifetime and at the time of his death hereinbefore mentioned seized or well entitled to him and his heirs in fee simple or for some and what other estate of inheritance of or to a certain real estate or how otherwise and whether such real estate did not consist of a messuage or Dwellinghouse farm hereditaments and premises situate at or near Peckham Rye in the parish of Saint Giles Camberwell in the County of Surrey or of what did such real estate consist of or how otherwise and whether he was not also in his lifetime and at the time of his death possessed of or entitled to some considerable or some and what personal estate and effects or how otherwise and whether such personal estate and effects did not consist amongst other particulars of household furniture plate linen china monies in the house implements of husbandry and stock and crops upon the aforesaid farm or of some and which of the aforesaid particulars or of some and what other or other particulars or how otherwise and whether the said Joseph Chambers being so seized possessed and entitled as aforesaid did not depart this life at or about the time hereinbefore in that behalf mentioned or at some and what other time or how otherwise and whether he did not die intestate and whether he made any and what will or how otherwise and whether he did not leave your Oratrix and the said Defendants Jane Mortlock and [struck: Joseph] ^Susannah^ Upsdell his only sister[s] him surviving or how otherwise and whether the said Intestate had not one other and what sister or how otherwise and whether such last mentioned sister did not die in his lifetime and when in particular or how otherwise and whether she did not leave the said Defendant James Salmon her eldest son and heir at law or who did she leave her heir at law or how otherwise and whether the said Intestate was ever and when married and to whom or how otherwise and whether he did [struck: not] leave any and what brother or issue of any brother or how otherwise and whether your Oratrix and the said Defendants Jane Mortlock Susannah Upsdell and James Salmon are not in manner aforesaid or in some and what other manner the coheirs of the said Intestate or how otherwise and whether your Oratrix and the said Defendants Jane Mortlock Susannah Upsdell and James Salmon or some and which of them are not also the persons who under the statute of distribution entitled to the residue of the said [struck: Testator] Intestate’s personal estate and effects or who else are or is entitled thereto or how otherwise and whether on or about the twenty fourth day of February one thousand eight hundred and thirty or at some and what other time letters of administration of the estate and effects of the said Intestate were not granted to your Oratrix and the said Defendants Jane Mortlock and Susannah Upsdell as the natural and lawful sisters of the said Intestate or how otherwise and whether your Oratrix and the said Defendants Jane Mortlock and Susannah Upsdell did not thereby become and are not now the legal personal representatives of the said Intestate or who else are or is such legal personal representatives or representative or how otherwise and whether your Oratrix or your Orator in her right or the said Defendant Jane Mortlock or the said Defendant her husband in her right have or has received or paid anything and what in [struck: particular] ^respect^ of the said Intestates personal estate or how otherwise And whether the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife or one and which of them were or was not stopping in the House with the said Intestate at the time of his death or how otherwise and whether upon his death they the said last mentioned Defendants or one and which of them did not possess themselves or himself or herself of the money in his house his household furniture plate linen and china and other and what effects and the stock crops implements of husbandry and other property upon his farm or how otherwise and whether they or one and which of them have or has not and when sold and converted into money the said stock and crops or some and what part thereof and some and what part of the said other effects or how otherwise and whether they the said Defendants last named or one and which of them have or has not out of the proceeds thereof or out of some and what other monies paid his the said Intestates funeral expences and just debts or some and what part thereof or how otherwise and whether the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife or one and which of them are or is not in the possession of all or some and what part of the residue of the said Intestates estate and effects and whether such residue is not to a considerable and what amount and value or how otherwise And whether the said Intestates debts were not to a very inconsiderable and what amount or how otherwise and whether the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife or one and which of them did not possess themselves or himself or herself of the several deeds and writings relating to the title of the said real estate or some and which of them or who else are in possession of the same or any or either and which of them or how otherwise and whether they did not also enter into the possession or into the receipt of the rents and profits of the said Intestates aforesaid real estate or how otherwise and whether they have or has not ever since […]

Signed in the left margin: Gatty

Notes on page 3

  • The interrogatories. This page is the formal list of questions each defendant had to answer on oath, repeating every point of the bill as a question (“whether … or how otherwise”). Their answers, if they survive, would confirm or deny each fact.
  • The clerk’s slip. In “Jane Mortlock and Joseph Upsdell” the clerk first wrote Joseph and corrected it to Susannah above the line.
  • “Whether the said Intestate was ever and when married and to whom”: the plaintiffs had already stated he was never married; the question asks the defendants to confirm it.
  • Nothing new about Sarah Ann’s identity on this page: she is again “your Oratrix”, one of the “natural and lawful sisters of the said Intestate”.

Page 4

Top of the page: 6 Aug[us]t 1830

[whether they have or has not ever since] been and are not now in the exclusive possession and enjoyment or in the receipt of the rents and profits of such Real Estate or who else are or is in such possession and enjoyment or receipt or howsoever And whether upon the death of the said Intestate your Oratrix and the said Defendants Susannah Upsdell Jane Mortlock and James Salmon or some and which of them did not become entitled to the said Intestates said Real Estates as Tenants in common in equal fourth parts or some and what other parts [struck: or shares] or how otherwise And your Oratrix or your Orator in her right and the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and William Mortlock in right of their respective wives are not entitled to equal fourth or some other and what parts of the residue of the said Intestates personal Estate and Effects or how otherwise And whether your Orator and Oratrix are not desirous of having a proper account taken of the said Intestates personal Estate and Effects and of his Funeral Expences and debts or how otherwise And whether your Orator and Oratrix are not also desirous of having the clear residue of such personal Estate ascertained and divided and distributed in manner aforesaid or how otherwise And whether the enjoyment of the said Real Estate in common is not attended with inconvenience or how otherwise And whether your Orator and Oratrix are not desirous of having a partition made thereof between the Coheirs in order that your Oratrix share and proportion thereof may be allotted to and held by your Oratrix in severalty or how otherwise And whether your Orator and Oratrix are not also desirous of having the Title Deeds and writings belonging to the Title to the said Estate deposited or disposed of in some proper manner for the benefit of the said Coheirs or how otherwise And whether your Orator and Oratrix are not also desirous of having a proper account taken of the rents and profits of the said Real Estates accrued due since the said Intestates death or an occupation rent set upon the same or how otherwise And whether your Orator and Oratrix are not desirous of having what is due and owing to your Oratrix or your Orator in her right in respect of your Oratrix’s fourth share of such rents and profits duly paid or how otherwise And whether your Orator and Oratrix have not made or caused to be paid [sic] to the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife or one and which of them applications and requests to such purport and effect as is hereinbefore in that behalf mentioned and setforth or some other and what applications and requests to some other and what purport or effect or how otherwise And whether the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife or one and which of them do or doth not absolutely refuse to comply with your Orator and Oratrix’s aforesaid requests or either and which of them and why or how otherwise And that the said Defendants may discover and setforth a full true and particular account of all and singular the personal Estate and Effects which the said Intestate was possessed of or entitled to at the time of his death together with the natures quantities qualities and true and utmost values thereof and of each and every part thereof and what parts thereof have come to the hands of the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife or either of them or to the hands of any other person or persons by their or either and which of their orders or for their or either and which of their use and of the application of the same or of such parts thereof as have been applied or disposed of and what parts thereof remain outstanding and where and in whose hands and why the same have not been collected and got in and also a like account of the funeral expences and just debts owing by the said Intestate at the time of his death and to whom and on what account the same were respectively owing and which of such debts have been paid and satisfied and out of what Funds and also the amount of the Money now in the hands of the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife in respect of the said [struck: Testators] ^Intestates^ Estate and Effects And that the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife may setforth a List or Schedule of the said Intestates real Estates and where the same are respectively situate and of the respective Rentals and annual value of the same since the death of the said Intestate together with an account of all the Rents and profits of such Real Estate which have accrued due since the said Intestates decease and by whom the same have from time to time been received and to what amount respectively and in respect of what premises and when the same became due and how the said Rents and Profits of the said Real Estates and every part thereof have been applied and disposed of and the amount of the Monies now in the hands of the said Confederates last named and in respect of the Rents and Profits of the said Intestates Real Estate And whether the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife or one and which of them did not attempt to procure Administration of the said Intestates personal Estate to [struck: be] be granted to the said Defendant Susannah Upsdell alone or how otherwise And whether your Orator and Oratrix did not prevent them from so doing or how otherwise And whether since that time or for some and what other reason the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his wife or one and which of them have or has not shewn much or some and what animosity and ill will towards your Orator and Oratrix and particularly towards your Orator and why or how otherwise And whether your Orator has not several or at some and what times or time applied to the said Defendant Isaac Upsdell to be allowed to inspect the accounts of the said Personal Estate or how otherwise

Signed in the left margin: Gatty

Notes on page 4

  • Four equal shares. The plaintiffs claim that Sarah Ann Johnson, Susannah Upsdell, Jane Mortlock and James Salmon (for his dead mother) took the Peckham Rye farm as tenants in common in equal fourth parts, and the same quarters of the personal estate.
  • What they want. An account of Joseph’s goods, debts and funeral costs; the clear residue divided; the farm partitioned so Sarah Ann’s quarter is set out for her alone; the title deeds put somewhere safe; and an account of rents since his death, or an “occupation rent” charged to whoever is living there (the Upsdells).
  • A family quarrel. The most personal passage: the Upsdells are said to have tried to get administration granted to Susannah alone, the Johnsons stopped them, and since then Isaac and Susannah have shown “animosity and ill will” towards the Johnsons, “particularly towards your Orator” (Mr Johnson). He had repeatedly asked Isaac to let him see the accounts.
  • Copying slips. “made or caused to be paid” is probably an error for “made or caused to be made”; “Testators” is again corrected to “Intestates”.

Page 5

Top of the page: 6 August 1830

And whether the said Defendant Isaac Upsdell has not repeatedly or at some and what times or time refused to allow your Orator on behalf of your Oratrix to inspect such accounts and why or how otherwise And whether considerable and what Stock and Crops have not been sold from off the said Farm or how otherwise And whether your Orator has not applied to the said Defendant Isaac Upsdell to inform him what the same were sold for and what was the expence attending the getting in and disposing of the said Stock and Crops or how otherwise And whether the said Defendant Isaac Upsdell has not positively refused to give your Orator any Information upon the Subject and why or how otherwise And whether some proper person ought not to be appointed a Receiver of the said Intestates Estate and Effects with the usual directions and if not why not or how otherwise And whether the said Defendants William Mortlock and Jane his Wife and James Salmon are not unwilling to join your Orator and Oratrix as Co Plaintiffs in this Suit and why or how otherwise

And that the said Defendants may answer the premises and that an Account may be taken by and under the direction and decree of this Honorable Court of the personal Estate and Effects which the said Intestate was possessed of or entitled to at the time of his Death which have been possessed by or come to the hands of the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his Wife or by any person or persons by their or either of their Order or for their or either of their use and of the application thereof and of the said Intestates funeral expences and just Debts and that such personal Estate and Effects may be applied so far as may be still necessary in a due course of Administration and that the clear residue of such personal Estate and Effects may be ascertained and divided and distributed amongst the parties entitled thereto and that a Commission of Partition may be issued out of and under the Seal of this Honorable Court and so directed to certain persons therein to be Named to divide and allot the said real Estate amongst the parties entitled as aforesaid and that they may severally hold their respective Allotments of the said real Estate to them and their heirs and assigns in Severalty and that the said Defendants may join with your Orator and Oratrix in making a proper Conveyance of the said premises for the purpose of effecting such partition and that the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his Wife may be [struck: directed] ^Decreed^ to produce the said Deeds and Writings in their custody or power belonging or relating to the Title to the said premises and that the same may be deposited or disposed of in some proper manner for the equal and mutual benefit of your Orator and Oratrix and the said Defendants and that an Account may be taken by and under the direction and decree of this Honorable Court of all the rents and profits of the said real Estate which have accrued due and been received by the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and his Wife or by any person or persons by their or either of their Order or for their or either of their use and that the said Defendants Isaac Upsdell and Susannah his Wife may be Decreed to pay to your Oratrix or to your Orator in her right her fourth part or share of what shall be found due upon that [struck: Account] ^account^ and that some proper person may be appointed a Receiver of the Estate and Effects of the said Intestate with the usual directions and that your Orator and Oratrix may have such further and other relief in the premises as to your Lordship shall seem meet and the nature and circumstances of the Case may require

May it please Your Lordship the premises considered to grant unto your Orator and Oratrix His Majesty’s most Gracious Writ or Writs of Subpoena to be directed to the said Isaac [struck: Upsdell] ^Upsdell^ and Susannah Upsdell his Wife William Mortlock and Jane Mortlock his Wife and James Salmon and the rest of their Confederates when discovered thereby commanding them and each and every of them at a certain day and under a certain pain to be limited personally to be and appear before your Lordship in this Honorable Court and then and there direct and perfect Answer make to all and singular the premises aforesaid and further to stand to perform and abide such further order direction and decree as to your Lordship shall seem meet and the nature and circumstances of the Case may require And your Orator and Oratrix[es] shall ever pray &c

C. P. Cooper

Signed in the left margin: Gatty

Notes on page 5

  • Stock and crops sold. The last interrogatories accuse Isaac Upsdell of selling “considerable” stock and crops off the farm and flatly refusing to tell Mr Johnson what they fetched or what the sale cost.
  • The Mortlocks and Salmon unwilling. Jane and William Mortlock and James Salmon had apparently declined to join the Johnsons as co-plaintiffs, which is why they are named as defendants alongside the Upsdells.
  • What the court is asked to do. Take accounts of Joseph’s personal estate and of the farm rents; pay debts and funeral costs and divide the residue; issue a Commission of Partition under the court’s seal so named commissioners could divide the Peckham Rye land into separate allotments, each held “in severalty”; make the Upsdells produce the title deeds; make them pay Sarah Ann her fourth share of the rents; and appoint a receiver.
  • The subpoena. The prayer asks for writs of subpoena against Isaac and Susannah Upsdell, William and Jane Mortlock and James Salmon to answer on oath.
  • Signatures. “C. P. Cooper” is counsel who signed the bill, very probably Charles Purton Cooper (1793–1873), the Chancery barrister and antiquary. “Gatty” in the margin of every page is the plaintiffs’ solicitor or clerk.
  • What to look for next. The defendants’ answers, and any decree or report on the partition, would be in other Chancery series (answers often in C 13 under the same case name; decrees and orders in C 33). A commission of partition usually ended with a return describing each allotment, which could show exactly how the Chambers farm at Peckham Rye was divided.

Order of 6 August 1830 (C 33/788, folio 2398)

Chancery entry book of decrees and orders, A book, 1830. The entry sits between Hobson v. Prodgers (5 August) and Barnes v. Wilson (29 June).

Margin: J ✓

Jn[o] Johnson and Wife — Pl[ain]t[iff]s Isaac Upsdell and Wife & or[s] — D[efendan]ts

Friday 6th Aug[us]t 1830

Upon the humble pet[itio]n of the Pl[ain]t[iff] this day pref[erred] unto the Right Hon[ora]ble the Master of the Rolls for the reasons therein cont[aine]d It is Ord[ere]d that the Pet[itione]r be at liberty to sue out process of Sub[poen]a ag[ain]st the D[efendan]ts to appear to and answer the pl[ain]t[iff]s Bill returnable immed[iatel]y — [initials, probably the registrar’s]

Notes on the order

  • Same day as the bill. The bill is dated 6 August 1830, and the Johnsons petitioned the Master of the Rolls that same day.
  • What was granted. Leave to issue the subpoena “returnable immediately”, so the defendants had to appear and answer at once rather than at the start of the next term. Trinity term was just ending and the long vacation was about to begin, which would otherwise have delayed the case until November. The Johnsons evidently wanted to stop the Upsdells selling more stock and crops or keeping the rents in the meantime.
  • Master of the Rolls. In 1830 this was Sir John Leach.
  • No further entry found yet. If the families settled privately (the partition deed is dated November 1830), there may be no later order. Any later order would be indexed under Johnson in the 1830 and 1831 indexes to the A books.
The document roll that included the legal case from 1830 – it was very large!

2.0 The Cousin matches that hinted at the truth

3.0 Joseph Chambers, Ann Medhurst and their child: Sarah Chambers

So yesterday when starting over to try and find Sarah Chambers I had a look for a marriage for Joseph. After a bit of digging I found one in Greenwich for a Joseph Chambers of Camberwell. For me this looked hopeful. He was married to an Ann Medhurst. Although she was clearly living in Greenwich in 1775 the marriage record gave no indication of where she was from originally. So the next thing I did was go back to my DNA – my mum was the one who had the main match to the Chambers family so I looked there first. She had many Medhurst matches. Four were to one family in Laughton Sussex who all had an Ann Medhurst of the right age. My mothers sister also had matches to this family.

I then considered baptisms and found baptisms for four children for Joseph and Ann in Camberwell but no Sarah. So having done this before I decided to look for a Sarah Chambers baptism in Sussex or Kent around the time of their marriage. And I found a baptism six months before their marriage for a Sarah Chambers with only an Ann Chambers mentioned. This generally signifies a birth out of wedlock. The baptism was in Beddingham which is a few miles from Laughton.

Even better the date was 1774 – this fits exactly with Sarah Harris’s marriage document which state that she was 22 when she married, the age on her census record in 1841 and the age on her death certificate in 1844.

I have yet to look fully at all my Harris DNA data sets but at least a couple also have good matches to this Medhurst family. So I am confident that this is good news. I also need to look to see if I can find matches to her siblings Peter, Ann and Rebecca Chambers descendants. I have not found them easy to trace so far.

4.0 Conclusions

In retrospect I think I should have realised that these Chambers matches were too hard to find for them to be siblings. I think I was always unsure that there was a link to this family at all – so when I did find a solid link I was carried away with it. Although it was a bit of a shock to discover my error yesterday after all my research into Sarah Ann and her sisters, it also feels great to have solved it – a true sleuthing exercise!

Researching siblings and the wider community around a brick wall really is the best way to take a project forward and I feel that this project has managed to show that.

Thanks go to the ten people with matches to this Chambers family who shared their DNA with me and many many trees that I used to build my Chambers tree. Without either of those I would not have been able to prove this. This really is a crowdsourced effort! I think if I had not had the clues about St Martin in the Fields I probably would never have found the Chambers family – so some luck involved here too.

Watch this space for further updates on this story. I will be following up the Medhurst DNA matches and I have a bit more to tell about the Chambers too.